The Persephone Book of Short Stories: Spade Man from Over the Water by Frances Towers


Frances Towers is not new to me. I have wanted to buy Tea with Mr. Rochester (Persephone Book #44), her only book (Frances Towers had died suddenly of pneumonia) for a while now. Spade Man from Over the Water is a short story which appears in Tea with Mr. Rochester as well, so this was a small teaser for me.

In Spade Man from Over the Water, Mrs. Asher and Mrs. Laura Penny are neighbors. While they are having tea together, a telegram comes for Laura announcing the arrival of her husband by the end of the week. Now Mrs. Asher has never met Laura’s husband. So she assumes the photograph on the mantelpiece must be of Laura’s husband and tells Laura the kind, fastidious, sensitive, and proud looking man in the picture looks like everything her husband should be!

Alas, it turns out the man in the picture is actually a cousin of Laura’s. Laura is dismayed her friend did not have the instincts to realize that it is not her husband. But Mrs. Asher is a dear, so she can’t possibly hold this mistake against her. After all, Mrs. Asher had made the “queenly gesture” of letting Laura run in and out of Miss. Lemon’s Cottage as she pleases after Laura had told Mrs. Asher that she had her heart set on the cottage before Mrs. Asher moved in there. Since then, for Laura, Mrs. Asher is a precious friend, and she is convinced their friendship would last long. So why does it all change when Laura shows a photo of her husband to Mrs. Asher?

I read the short story twice to see if I can figure out what exactly happened in the end, however, I’m clueless yet! The story’s ending is open to interpretation. For me, it had a supernatural feeling. A very strange story and I’m still curious to read Tea with Mr. Rochester!


  1. Sounds intriguing. Your short story reviews have convinced me to buy my own copy of the Persephone collection, and to delve into it. Thank you!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. You are welcome! I love Persephone books. I have read seven Persephones so far, but this is my first time reading a Persephone short story collection.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. […] the spell was cast, so what brought them together? I’m clueless, just as I was when I read Spade Man from Over the Water by Frances […]


  3. […] ever published. Last year I came across one of her stories in The Persephone Book of Short Stories. Spade Man from Over the Water which hinted at the supernatural is usually not my cup of tea, nonetheless, it made me want to […]


  4. […] four more stories left for me in this collection as I’ve already read Spade Man from Over the Water, and I’m already feeling sad, but I’m sure there will be more Persephones for me to […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: